Steel garage door with bottom panel rusted that is a prime candidate for single panel replacement.

Garage Door Panel Replacement

A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners
At Forest Garage Doors, we understand how frustrating it can be when one or more of your garage door panels are damaged. Whether from an accidental bump, harsh weather, or natural wear and tear, damaged garage door panels can diminish both the functionality and appearance of your garage door. Fortunately, replacing the affected panels can be a practical and cost-effective solution—especially if the damage is isolated. However, how do you know when to replace individual panels or when it's time for a full garage door replacement? This guide will help you determine when to opt for garage door panel replacement and why Forest Garage Doors is your best choice for high-quality, durable panel replacements.

Table of Contents

Can You Replace Just One Panel?

In many cases, yes—replacing just one damaged panel is possible and cost-effective. However, it’s important to have the door inspected by a professional to ensure that no hidden structural issues are present. If there is underlying damage to the door frame or other panels, replacing just one section might not solve the problem and could affect the overall functionality of the door.

Example of one garage door that is a candidate for single panel replacement, and another that is not.
The photo on the left is an example where replacing the entire door may be a more cost-effective solution. Where the door shown in the right photo may be eligible for a single panel replacement.

When Should You Replace Garage Door Panels?

Not every case of garage door damage requires a complete door replacement. Sometimes, replacing a single panel is the most effective solution, especially if:

  • The damage is isolated: If just one or two panels are damaged while the rest of your door is in good condition, replacing the damaged sections might be the most cost-effective option.
  • Cosmetic damage is minor: If the damage doesn’t affect the functionality of your garage door—such as a minor dent or scratch—replacing the panel can restore your door’s look without needing a completely new one.
  • The panel type is available: If matching replacement panels are available for your door’s model and design, then a straightforward replacement of the damaged panels makes sense.

At Forest Garage Doors, we work with top vendors like Hormann, North Central Door Company, Oxford Carriage Door, Carriage House Door Company, and Richards-Wilcox. This allows us to source the perfect replacement panels for both modern and classic garage doors, ensuring a seamless fit and finish.

Custom Wooden Panels for Older Garage Doors

One of the unique advantages of working with Forest Garage Doors is our ability to provide custom-built wooden panels for older or vintage garage doors. If your home has a classic wooden garage door, finding matching replacement panels can be challenging. That’s where we come in. We can craft custom wooden panels that perfectly complement the style and design of your existing door, allowing you to maintain the charm and authenticity of your home.

Whether you have a modern steel door or a vintage wooden model, we have the skills and resources to restore your door to its original beauty.

Garage door wood panel replacement

When to Consider a Full Garage Door Replacement

While panel replacement is often a viable option, there are cases where replacing the entire garage door might be more practical and cost-effective:

  • The door is old: If your garage door is over 15 years old, it may be better to replace the entire door rather than just the damaged panels. Older doors tend to have worn-out insulation and may not meet current safety and efficiency standards.
  • Multiple panels are damaged: If more than one or two panels are affected, it might make more sense to invest in a full replacement, as the costs of replacing several panels can add up.
  • The design no longer fits your home’s style: If you’ve remodeled your home or your needs have changed, replacing the entire door gives you the opportunity to upgrade both the look and functionality of your garage door.

What Does Garage Door Panel Replacement Cost?

The cost of replacing garage door panels varies based on factors such as the type of door, materials used, and labor. For example:

  • Sectional garage doors are the most common type and have a lower replacement cost per panel. These panels can range from $250 to $1,000.
  • Roll-up doors generally cost between $150 and $400 to replace a panel.
  • Tilt-up doors and side-sliding doors tend to be more expensive, with replacement panels ranging from $400 to $3,000.

The cost of labor depends on the complexity of the job and the type of door. For a standard sectional door, labor costs typically range from $200 to $500.

How to Replace Garage Door Panels

Garage door panel replacement is a complex and potentially dangerous process, as it involves working with heavy components and tension springs. For safety and precision, it’s recommended to leave this task to a professional. Here’s an overview of how professionals like the team at Forest Garage Doors handle panel replacement:

  1. Source the correct replacement panel: We ensure that the new panel matches the size, style, and material of your existing door.
  2. Prepare the door for replacement: The door is secured, and spring tension is adjusted if necessary for a safe replacement.
  3. Remove the damaged panel: Using specialized tools, we carefully remove the damaged panel without affecting other parts of the door.
  4. Install the new panel: The replacement panel is installed and aligned with the rest of the door.
  5. Test and adjust the door: After installation, we test the garage door’s functionality and make any necessary adjustments to ensure smooth operation.

FAQ About Garage Door Panel Replacement

No, garage door panels are not universal. They come in different sizes, thicknesses, and materials depending on the manufacturer. At Forest Garage Doors, we help you find or custom-build the exact panels needed for your door.
The replacement process generally takes between three and four hours, depending on the size and complexity of the door. This includes securing the door, removing the damaged panel, installing the new panel, and testing the door for proper functionality.
Panel replacement costs vary, but it’s often more affordable than replacing the entire door. Depending on the material and design, panel costs range from $150 to $1,000, with labor fees adding to the total.

Trust Forest Garage Doors for Your Panel Replacement Needs

At Forest Garage Doors, we are committed to providing high-quality, durable garage door panel replacements. With access to top brands and the ability to craft custom wooden panels for older doors, we can restore your garage door to its original condition, ensuring both functionality and aesthetic appeal.

Contact us today for a free consultation and let us help you determine whether panel replacement or a full garage door replacement is the best solution for your home. Call us at (708) 652-9405 or click the button below to fill out our form.

Here for You in 1946 … Here for You Today. Work With the Best.

With decades of expertise, Forest Garage Doors stands as a pinnacle in garage door services. Our rich history ensures unmatched knowledge and reliability, setting us apart as industry leaders since 1946.

Share this post

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *